The Disappearance of Third-Party Cookies

Third-party cookies have been around for decades but are disappearing. What does this mean?

Introduction: What Does This Mean?

I'm sure that you the reader have been accessing the internet using a web browser for a few years now. If that's the case, you've been getting third-party cookies on your browser.

Third-party cookies, small pieces of data placed on a user's device (most commonly in your web browsers) by websites other than the one the user is currently visiting, have been essential for tracking browsing history across different sites. This tracking enables personalized ads based on users' online activities.

Major web browsers such as Firefox and Safari have already implemented third-party cookies restrictions. However, Google Chrome's phasing out of third-party cookies marks a significant shift in internet privacy and digital marketing.

Google Chrome's announcement highlights how this change will affect various stakeholders, from internet users to marketers, content creators, and SEO practitioners. Google Chrome plans to restrict third-party cookies fully by Q3 2024.

As this will impact nearly everyone who uses the internet, I've summarized how I think it will affect us, focusing on us as consumers, as advertisers, content creators, marketers and SEO practitioners.

How This Will It Impact You

Google Chrome has a worldwide share of 65%. It is big enough and it will impact how we use the internet.

1. Enhanced Privacy

Users will experience increased privacy protection as their browsing habits will be less easily tracked across multiple websites.

2. Less Personalized Advertising

Without third-party cookies, users may see fewer targeted ads based on their browsing history, potentially resulting in a less personalized online experience.

3. Potential Website Functionality Issues

Some websites that rely heavily on third-party cookies for certain features may experience functionality problems. Users might need to temporarily re-enable cookies for these sites to work properly.

4. Changes in User Experience

As advertisers and marketers adapt to the new landscape, users may notice changes in how websites and online services interact with them.

5. Increased Transparency

Users will likely become more aware of data collection practices as companies seek alternative methods to gather user information.

This change is part of Google's Privacy Sandbox initiative, aimed at improving user privacy while still allowing for effective online advertising. The full impact of this change will become clearer as it rolls out to more users and as the digital marketing industry adapts to the new reality of a cookieless web.

Impact on Digital Advertising

If you're in advertising and put out ads on the internet, this change will impact you.

1. Reduced Precision in Ad Targeting

Without third-party cookies, advertisers will lose access to detailed cross-site browsing data, making it more challenging to deliver highly personalized ads based on users' online behaviour.

2. Shift to Alternative Targeting Methods

Advertisers will need to adapt by focusing more on first-party data, zero-party data, and new technologies like Google's Federated Learning of Cohorts (FLoC) to reach their target audiences.

3. Potential Decrease in Ad Effectiveness

The loss of granular user data may lead to less relevant ads being shown to users, potentially reducing click-through rates and overall ad performance.

4. Changes in Ad Pricing

With less detailed targeting data available, marketers may be less willing to pay premium prices for ad inventory, potentially leading to reduced ad income for publishers.

5. Increased Focus on First-Party Data

Advertisers and marketers will need to prioritize collecting and leveraging first-party data directly from their websites and platforms.

6. Privacy-Centric Advertising Approaches

The industry will likely shift towards more privacy-friendly advertising methods that respect user consent and preferences.

7. Challenges in Measurement and Attribution

Without third-party cookies, it will become more difficult to measure campaign performance and attribute conversions across different touchpoints.

8. Innovation in Ad Tech

The phase-out of third-party cookies is driving innovation in the ad tech industry, with new solutions being developed to balance effective advertising with user privacy.

While these changes present challenges for the digital advertising industry, they also create opportunities for more privacy-conscious and innovative approaches to targeted advertising. Advertisers and marketers who adapt quickly to this new landscape will be better positioned to succeed in the post-cookie era.

Impact on Marketers, Content Creators, and SEO Practitioners

Apart from advertisers and advertising, there is a wide-ranging impact on the way how we present our content to our users and customers too.

For Marketers

1. Reduced Targeting Precision

Marketers will lose access to detailed cross-site browsing data, making it more challenging to deliver highly personalized ads.

2. Shift to First-Party Data

There will be an increased focus on collecting and leveraging first-party data directly from owned websites and platforms.

3. New Targeting Methods

Marketers will need to adapt by using alternative targeting methods like Google's FLoC or contextual advertising.

4. Changes in Measurement and Attribution

It will become more difficult to measure campaign performance and attribute conversions across different touchpoints.

5. Emphasis on Consent-Based Marketing

Permission marketing and explicit user consent will become more important for targeting and personalization.

For Content Creators

1. Increased Importance of First-Party Relationships

Content creators will need to focus more on building direct relationships with their audience to gather valuable data.

2. Shift in Content Strategy

There may be a greater emphasis on creating content that encourages user engagement and data sharing.

3. Potential Changes in Ad Revenue

As targeted advertising becomes less precise, content creators may see changes in ad revenue from programmatic advertising.

For SEO Practitioners

1. Greater Focus on Contextual Relevance

With less reliance on user-specific data, the importance of creating content that matches user intent and context will increase.

2. Emphasis on First-Party Data Optimization

SEO practitioners will need to help businesses optimize their websites to collect and utilize first-party data effectively.

3. Increased Importance of On-Site Engagement

Keeping users on-site and encouraging them to interact with content will become more crucial for gathering valuable data.

4. Adaptation to New Tracking Methods

SEO practitioners will need to stay updated on new tracking and measurement technologies that emerge to replace third-party cookies.

Impact on Japanese Businesses

Like any other major paradigm shift in the past, the removal of third-party cookies will present both challenges and opportunities for Japanese businesses. I will list them out here while referring to the survey data compiled by Nyle Inc.

Challenges

1. Increased Focus on First-Party Data

Japanese marketers and content creators will need to prioritize collecting and leveraging first-party data directly from their websites and platforms.

2. Adaptation to New Technologies

Japanese advertisers will need to explore alternative targeting methods, such as Google's Privacy Sandbox or contextual advertising, to replace third-party cookie functionality.

3. Emphasis on Contextual Targeting

There will likely be a shift towards AI-based marketing techniques like context targeting, which doesn't rely on user behaviour history.

4. Shift in Advertising Priorities

Content marketing (46.2%), SEO (38.4%), and social media marketing (31.3%) are now considered the most important digital marketing strategies. This suggests a move towards more organic, content-driven approaches.

Opportunities

1. Levelling the Playing Field

The removal of third-party cookies could benefit small businesses by reducing the advantage that larger companies have in terms of access to extensive user data. This will allow smaller companies to compete on the merit of their content and offerings.

If you're a small business and need to compete better with your content, Kafkai can help you do just that.

2. Increased Digital Marketing Budgets

About 60% of respondents reported an increase in their digital marketing budgets over the past year, indicating a growing focus on digital channels. The top strategy for dealing with the cookie phase-out is using cookie-less advertising from major platforms like Google and Meta (63.5%). Other popular approaches include leveraging first-party data (47.4%) and strengthening non-advertising digital marketing initiatives (39.4%).

3. Mixed Response to Cookie Phase-Out

Despite the impending removal of third-party cookies, about 50% of companies reported increasing their advertising budgets, while 30% maintained their current spending levels.

4. Increasing Focus on AI

About 30% of respondents are considering or implementing AI-enhanced marketing strategies, indicating a growing trend towards AI adoption in the industry. There are huge opportunities for AI content creation, SEO practitioners, and platform providers to take up the vacuum left by third-party cookies. At the same time, only 50% of companies have taken measures to prepare for the cookie-less future, with about 30% yet to implement any countermeasures. This represents an untapped market.

Wrapping Up

The takeaway from all this is that it will require professionals across digital marketing, content creation, and SEO to adapt their strategies, focusing more on privacy-compliant methods, first-party data collection, and creating value for users to encourage direct engagement.

If you're interested in reading more on this, these sources might help: